Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Tom And Bill's Original Cheese Ring
Brat & Kraut
Bbq Chicken
Bacon Cheeseburger
About
Random Lake Pizzeria
Welcome to Random Lake Pizzeria, a charming gem nestled in the heart of Random Lake, Wisconsin. Located at 435 2nd St, this delightful eatery has made a name for itself with its delectable range of pizzas and warm, inviting atmosphere. As a food lover and reviewer for Foodjoyy, I'm excited to share the unique offerings and inviting environment that make this pizzeria a must-visit.
One of the standout features at Random Lake Pizzeria is their inventive cheese ring variations. From the savory Gyro Ring to the spicy Ring of Fire, each ring is a delightful twist on the classic pizza experience. The attention to creativity shines through in every bite. The Jenny's Ring is particularly beloved among locals, offering a taste sensation that pairs perfectly with their freshly made pizzas.
- Garlic Bread – A tempting starter at just US$4.77.
- Cheese Bread – A great shareable option for US$5.77.
- Breadsticks – Perfectly baked for US$5.00, with a cheesy twist available for only US$5.55.
Customers rave about the thin-crust pizzas that are made from the freshest ingredients. Nancy Severn highlights the well-crafted crust and praises the cozy decor, including the unique "bathroom maps wallpaper." Katelyn DuPont echoes her sentiments, sharing her love for the creative menu, which features everything from gyro pizza to Mac and cheese pizza. It's not just the food; the genuine kindness of the staff makes every visit a memorable one.
But it doesn't stop there. Random Lake Pizzeria also offers mouthwatering homemade ice cream, an absolute must-try. Nick L was particularly impressed by the salted toffee Nice Cream, claiming it's far superior to popular chains like Culver’s. Patrons can sit and enjoy the charming atmosphere or choose to dine al fresco at one of their lovely outdoor tables.
The positive reviews keep flowing in, with TL Koch recommending the pizzeria for its creative offerings and relaxed vibe. David Willis’s praise for the Steak and Blue pizza and the Jenny cheese ring further solidifies the location as a place where flavors and craftsmanship converge beautifully.
In conclusion, Random Lake Pizzeria is more than just a pizza place. It’s a community haven where quality meets creativity in each dish. Whether you're local or just passing through, make it a priority to experience the rich flavors and warm hospitality that this pizzeria has to offer. Trust me; after one visit, you'll be coming back for more!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Delicious thin crust pizza! Next time I am also trying a calzone...they look great!Clean cozy restaurant! Great collection of decor. Love the bathroom maps "wallpaper". The owner and family are genuine! ”
“ Michigander here! Saw all the good reviews and wanted to check this place out myself! It was so cute inside, I loved the vibe. Got garlic bread, cheese dippers, gyro pizza, and Mac and cheese pizza with a friend. SO delicious. Everyone there was so nice, and our server was amazing! We sat inside but they have cute tables outside too. You can also pick up a brew and enjoy some AWESOME homemade ice cream. 10/10 will be going back every time I can. ”
“ Freshest ingredients and dough we’ve ever had on a pizza. We got a quart of the salted toffee Nice Cream and it is by far better than any others especially Culver’s. Can’t wait to go back !! ”
“ A friend and I had a great first visit to this pizza place. (I live about 20 minutes away.) The atmosphere was welcoming, and the service was friendly. We tried four of their specialty pizzas, and each one was unique and delicious. Highly recommended for anyone who loves creative pizza and a relaxed, enjoyable dining experience. We’ll definitely be back! ”
“ Steak and Blue pizza was the best. Jenny cheese ring. Unfortunately we were to full to get the home made ice cream. ”
“ Went here for dinner with a large group of friends and ordered the Gyro Salad and Calzone. The gyro meat on the salad was nicely sized, extremely tender, and very well seasoned. The salad mix that came with it was well proportioned, and both tasted just as good the next day as leftovers. The breadstick was dense, warm, and incredibly delicious. You can tell the dough is handmade. The sausage calzone was not too big, and the handmade dough here did not soften or get soggy on the bottom. After reheating the next day, the crust held its firmness, and the calzone was just as flavorful. The interior of this place is pretty eclectic, with lots to draw your attention to. It's family orientated, and the wait staff is incredible. Tom was fast, extremely patient, and friendly. He was kind enough to grant our requests for separate checks and took the time to socialize with us. This is a great spot with great food and good people. ”
“ We had a soccer game and came here to eat after. The food was SO good and the owner was so nice and it was also really fast service. We will definitely be here again. We got kids pizzas and ours and my father in law got a sandwich. 10/10 ”
“ My wife and I stumbled upon this pizzeria after a long day of hiking at Harrington Beach State park. The reviews were good so we decided to give it a shot. First impressions, it was cozy and inviting atmosphere with an fun mixture of tribal meets hometown decor. It's clearly a place where many people enjoy going with the kids artwork on the walls and the many hand prints of happy visitors. We were quickly greeted by a friendly gentlemen, who we assume is the owner. He seemed genuine and friendly without the usual restaurant mantra that many corporate chains push. The menus are simple but have plenty of options. We split a cheese ring before our pizza which was delicious! I got a landmark pizza which could be considered a "deluxe" pie and my wife got a gyro pizza. Both were incredible. In fact, I believe its the best pizza I've had since moving to Wisconsin. Neither of us finished our pizzas to we took it to go and when he brought us our check, he also brought us a bowl of their homemade "nice cream" as they call it to try on the house. It was really good! We would have both gotten more if we had room for it. We really enjoyed our experience here. It was really refreshing to eat at a hometown establishment when were used to the hustle of the Milwaukee area. Next time were up in the Random Lake area, we will definitely be stopping by again! ”